The society of leaf cutter ants may not be so utopian after all credit Dirk van der Made

“The accepted theory was that queens were produced solely by nurture - certain larvae were fed certain foods to prompt their development into queens and all larvae could have that opportunity,” said Dr Hughes.

However, the team carried out DNA fingerprinting on five colonies of leaf-cutting ants and discovered that the offspring of some fathers are more likely to become queens than others. These ants have a ‘royal’ gene or genes, giving them an unfair advantage and enabling them to cheat many of their altruistic sisters out of their chance to become a queen themselves.

But what intrigued the scientists was that these ‘royal’ genetic lines were always rare in each colony.

Dr Hughes said: “The most likely explanation has to be that the ants are deliberately taking steps to avoid detection. If there were too many of one genetic line developing into queens in a single colony, the other ants would notice and might take action against them. So we think the males with these royal genes have evolved to somehow spread their offspring around more colonies and so escape detection. The rarity of the royal lines is actually an evolutionary strategy by the cheats to escape suppression by the altruistic masses that they exploit.”

A few times each year, ant colonies produce males and new queens which fly off from their colonies to meet and mate. The males die shortly after mating and the females go on to found new colonies. The researchers are keen to study this process, to determine if their hypothesis is correct and the mating strategy of males with royal genes ensures their rarity, to keep their advantages undetected by their ‘commoner’ counterparts.

The work is published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA.